Thursday
September 02, 2010


News
Calendar
Viewpoints
Editorials
Letters
Ken Trainor
Shrubtown
Lifelines
Sports
Journal Plus

Blogs

Community Guide
Special Sections

About Us
Feedback
Send us letters



Legal Notices






Search


Advanced Search

home : viewpoints : viewpoints

10/21/2008 10:00:00 PM Email this articlePrint this article 
The liberals seem to have their 'man of action'
Jim Bowman

Did you ever see so many political signs? The Big O has Oak Park in a hammerlock. But you John-and-Sarah supporters-don't you just love her?-need not fear. Oak Park's Republican committeewoman, Marlene Lynch, has a few left of the ten (10!) signs she got from the Cook County party. She'd prefer not having her number given out, however. Republicans lie low in Oak Park.


Meanwhile, Big O signs metastasize, and so what? He's most Oak Parkers' beau ideal. Heck, I met him at a reception for him in an
Oak Park home in the mid-'90s, before few besides William Ayers, that unrepentant son of a ComEd CEO, knew his potential. He was running Annenberg Challenge, funding school programs in how to overthrow the government and helping ACORN register voters as only ACORN knows how-look them up under vote fraud. Little did I know, sipping wine and munching cheese, what a giant was in our midst.


He was a community organizer, as we know. We had that sort of thing next door in
Austin in the '60s when the Organization for a Better Austin (OBA), a Saul Alinsky operation, was headquartered in the St. Catherine of Siena rectory. In 1968 I rented an apartment at Lotus and Lake in an OBA-approved building reserved for whites with Baird & Warner's cooperation. It was integration, Alinsky style.


Tom Gaudette, a Boston Irishman, headed the operation. Young activist Jesuits sometimes found his methods incompatible with their "theology," they told him. Tom was an Alinsky man. Alinsky was the absolute charmer of a guy who described Jesus as a community organizer.


Alinsky was also French Catholic philosopher Jacques Maritain's idea of a wonderful individual. "Jacques dear: I wept over your letter," wrote Alinsky in response to Maritain's words of consolation on the death of his first wife. When Alinsky died, the late Msgr. Jack Egan and columnist and one-time Alinsky organizer Nick Von Hoffman cried together over the phone.


Alinsky is also the guy who told Look Magazine, "If the end doesn't justify the means, what does?" Battling the corporate enemy in
Rochester, N.Y., he bragged, "When I get through with Eastman Kodak, there won't be enough toilet paper in the world to wipe them clean." In Rules for Radicals, he explains: "The man of action" sees an issue "in pragmatic and strategic terms," thinking "only of his actual resources and the possibilities of various choices of action." He asks, "only whether [this or that means] will work." He rejects "the immaculate conception of ends and principles."


Forget corruption: "Life is a corrupting process," he wrote. "He who fears corruption fears life." Etc. Chilling stuff, which I once ate up, from a red-queen sort who decides what words mean and tells you to deal with it. The "man of action" business is particularly foreboding. It's a staple of fascism, of course. Mussolini, Hitler, and FDR were a mutual admiration society before the stuff hit the fan in the matter of Jewish people being rounded up and beaten up and eventually much worse-the German contribution to fascism. The political appeal was based on admiration for the strong man who brooked no opposition.


Mussolini was crafty about it and inspired admiration in "progressive" circles in this country, as he had admired American pragmatism in Woodrow Wilson, the college professor-become-president with a yen for power that puts even today's tenured radicals to shame. Then came FDR, the roaring pragmatist, and then Hitler. Progressives, later called liberals, yet later progressives again-the name changes keep them ahead of the awareness curve-love the man of action.


Now they have one. He's The One, our smooth-talking Democrat presidential candidate with a yen for deciding how much you should earn before being hit with a tax hike-to "spread the wealth around," as he unfortunately told that plumber in
Ohio. Could this be the slip that sinks Big O's ship?

 





Reader Comments


Posted: Thursday, October 30, 2008
Article comment by: Gregg Mumm

Mr. Bowman seems to know next to nothing of political theory and exhibits no grasp of basic history. FDR tried to prepare the country to resist fascism, against the opposition of homegrown Nazi-sympathizers, like Colonel Charles Lindbergh of the "America First Committee," the anti-semitic Father Charles Coughlin, and the predominently isolationist Republican Party. I'm fighting myself to hold back, but if there are any parallels to be drawn between fascism and American politics presently then it is to the current administration and the Republican party, with its approach of big government linked with private big business as an adjunct a predoninently neo-con militaristic,expansionistic, no-negotiation foreign policy an overwrought glorification of uncritical fidelity to our country (a gross contamination of patriotism the degredation of civil liberties and the xenophobic and rascist strands in the Republican party. Because comparisons with the unprecedented pure evil of Hitler should probably never be drawn, perhaps we can call it "fascism light" (although the stomach churns attaching "light" to the word "fascism"). And finally, isn't wonderful that Obama is desparately, but absurdly, being labelled a "socialist" and a "communist." It reveals further theoretical confusion in the opposition and signals the long overdue rehabilitation of "liberalism:" "liberal" and "liberalism" are apparently no longer scary enough to achieve the reaction sought by the fear mongers on the right. Liberalism is making an entirely deserved comeback, striking the correct balance, as it does, between the cold-blooded, dog-eat-dog heartless selfishness of pure capitalism and the disfunctionality of selfless socialism.

Posted: Sunday, October 26, 2008
Article comment by: Jim Bowman

* Garfunkel is right: Between FDR and Mussolini was mutual admiration, between FDR and Hitler it was one-sided. Hitler admired FDR, period, unless we accept the claim at www.marxist.com, a site "In defense of Marxism," where Yossi Schwarz states flatly, "Britain's Churchill and US President Roosevelt admired Hitler and Mussolini for their tough anti-communist and anti-union policies." This was not my source, however.

Mine, slightly misread by me in this case, was Jonah Goldberg's "Liberal Fascism," which cites standard sources voluminously to make the point that fascism looked very good to liberals and New Dealers in the '30s. One quote sticks out for me: FDR was warned by former Winnetka resident, Sec. of Interior Harold Ickes that the public was increasingly inclined "to unconsciously group four names, Hitler, Stalin, Mussolini and Roosevelt," as Ickes said in his 1953 book "The Secret Diary of Harold Ickes: the First Thousand Days."

In any case, and this is Goldberg's argument, liberalism resembles fascism, and no one made any bones about it until Hitler went after the Jews, giving a lasting bad name for what was thought by many to be the answer to our problems. I recommend Goldberg's book, published by Doubleday, subtitled "The Secret History of the American Left from Mussolin to the Politics of Meaning," which bristles with footnotes and bibliography.


Posted: Saturday, October 25, 2008
Article comment by: Tom Broderick

McPalunacy.

Posted: Thursday, October 23, 2008
Article comment by: Ray Simpson

We can show support for John and Sarah by flying the American Flag. My casual survey of South Oak Park notes that I have observed only one home with an Obama sign AND an AMERICAN flag flying.
Ray Simpson


Posted: Wednesday, October 22, 2008
Article comment by: John Krzyskowski

Regarding Jim Bowman's column on Obama: I was only a few paragraphs in when my skin started to crawl, and I began looking for signs that I was overreacting, that maybe this was just a bad piece of satire or something, but no--he definitely was not kidding!

After this, it will be tough to take seriously--actually, to even bother reading--anything that pops up under Bowman's byline.

It's like this: Say you have this neighbor, and he's always seemed to be a decent, reasonable guy, and then he starts buttonholing you about how the country is being colonized by aliens who are abducting large swaths of the population and replacing them with humanoid zombies bent on world domination.

Then it's not long before you start crossing to the other side of the street when you see him coming, because the whole situation is just so embarrassing, and besides, by now he probably thinks you're one of them, and who knows what might happen next.

See you later, Jim. Much, much later.


Posted: Wednesday, October 22, 2008
Article comment by: Richard J. Garfunkel

My problem with the right is that it has used "fear" as its mantra for all of time. It has aligned itself with wealth, greed, state religion, censorship and its view of "the sermon on the mount." In other words the meek shall inherit the earth, but while here might makes right. Maybe the liberals are bleeding hearts at time, but being liberal, wanting regulation and a fair playing field,and access to opportunity doesn't make them "commie rats." The reforms of state, corporate and religious abuse have come from the left. To associate Wilson and FDR with Mussolini and Hitler is a slander. It was Hitler who copied the writings of Americans like Henry Ford and eugenics movement. You speak of FDR in the same breath with Hitler. he hated Hitler, and certainly didn't love Germans and their arrogant and militaristic ways. he learned that early on his trips to Baden. He was an early advocate against German and worldwide totalitarianism with Quarantine Speech, but the conservative isolationists screamed and yelled that he had usurped his role as president. These paragons of purity called for his impeachment over that speech. In the same vein GW Bush should have been indicted and thrown out of office a hundred times. Personally I am tired of the flat-earth, Luddites of the right hiding behind the flag and patriotism. They are what they are the merchants of fear and hatred. If it were for the conservatives we would still be in the caves, worrying about sunburn.
RJ Garfunkel
Tarrytown, NY


Article Comment Submission Form
Please feel free to submit your comments.

Article comments are not posted immediately to the Web site. Each submission must be approved by the Web site editor. There may be a delay of 24-48 hours for any submission while the Web site editor reviews and approves it.

Note: All information on this form is required. Your telephone number and e-mail address are for our use only, and will not be attached to your comment.
Name:
Telephone:
E-mail:
Passcode: This form will not send your comment unless you copy exactly the passcode seen below into the text field. This is an anti-spam device to help reduce the automated email spam coming through this form.

Please copy the passcode exactly
- it is case sensitive.
Message:
   






Copyright 2010, Wednesday Journal, Inc.,
141 S. Oak Park Ave., Oak Park, IL 60302, 708-524-8300

To view any of the publications owned and operated
by Wednesday Journal, Inc., click on the appropriate title.

Forest Park Review · Riverside Brookfield Landmark
Chicago Journal · Skyline · Austin Weekly News · Chicago Parent magazine


Copyright 2010, Wednesday Journal Inc.

Software © 1998-2010 1up! Software, All Rights Reserved